The President's Economic Advisory Council, an esteemed body of experts that so far has remained above the daily political fray, is now deep in it.
Two contrary briefing notes addressed to the President Cyril Ramaphosa have found their way into the media within a week. Bear in mind that the council has very seldom leaked. Its reports go straight to the president and don't enter the public domain.
The issue is one of the most contentious policy proposals of the democratic era: the institutionalising of a permanent income grant for the poor. While public sentiment broadly is in favour of a grant given SA's dire poverty levels, economists and policymakers are sharply divided.
Those whose political responsibility is social protection, such as the social development department and others, strongly support a permanent income grant. Those charged with taking care of the country's public finances warn that the risks of such a decision weigh heavily.